Skip to content

I Stained My Deck The Wrong Color – What To Do

Staining a deck is a popular way to enhance different types of wood and protect it from the elements. However, what happens when you realize you stained your deck the wrong color? Don’t panic! Mistakes happen, and staining a deck the wrong color can be disheartening. The good news is that there are steps you can take to address the issue and make things right. One of the first things to consider is whether the stain is still wet or has already dried. If it’s still wet, you can immediately correct the color by wiping or rinsing off the stain and finish.

If the stain has dried, the process becomes more involved, and you must ensure your deck is in good condition. One option is to apply another layer of semi-transparent stain on top of the existing tint, using a color closer to your desired outcome. However, it’s crucial to test the new stain on a small, inconspicuous section of the deck first to ensure it produces the desired color before you cover the whole deck.

Sanding can be time-consuming, but it allows you to remove the existing stain and start fresh completely. Another option is to consider solid color stains, which provide a more opaque finish and can help cover up the previous color. However, remember that solid stains will hide the natural wood grain. When changing the deck stain, follow the manufacturer’s instructions and how-to. Our guide shows that staining your deck the wrong color doesn’t have to be a permanent mistake.

I Stained My Deck The Wrong Color

By the end, you’ll know several options to cover up or eliminate the wrong deck stain color. You’re looking at a little extra work and expense, yet you’ll have ways to fix this so it looks like new wood.

How to Tell if You Stained Your Deck Color Wrong

If you recently stained your deck (or use on top of kitchen tabletop) and the color didn’t turn out as expected, don’t panic. The first thing to do is confirm whether you applied the wrong stain color before stripping it. Look at your chosen color on the can and compare it with what’s on your deck. If it doesn’t match, then you’ve used the wrong one.

Your deck may have been stained incorrectly because you only applied one coat of stain instead of two. A second coat is always recommended for a consistent finish and complete coverage, especially if you’re staining over an existing coat or changing colors significantly. (Learn How Much Weight Can Drive Over A Septic Tank)

how to lighten

How Do You Lighten Stained Deck After Applying?

Lightening the color is possible, but it’s not an easy task. The first thing to do is wait for the stain to dry completely. Then, you can use bleach or a deck brightener to remove some of the color.  Before applying any bleach or brightener. Test the stain on a small section or a similar piece of wood of your deck first before applying stain to the entire deck surface.

This will ensure you won’t accidentally damage your wood’s surface if the product doesn’t work as expected. Use a paintbrush to apply the product evenly and let it sit for at least 15 minutes before rinsing it with water. Remember that these products (Cabot or a different brand) can also lighten the natural wood color of your deck, so be prepared for potential changes in shade. If all else fails, consider sanding down your entire deck and starting over with a new stain color that suits your tastes, then apply the finish.


5 Ways You Can Change Your Wrong Deck Color

If you’ve stained your deck the wrong color, don’t panic. There are a few steps you can take to fix it. First, if only a small section has been stained the wrong color, consider just sanding down that area and re-staining it with the correct color.

Hand sanding would be best in this case to avoid any damage to the surrounding areas. Another option is to use a deck stripper or paint remover to remove the stain from the entire deck and start with the correct color.

Stains in Solid Colors

If you have stained your deck with the wrong color, don’t worry. There are several things you can do to mitigate the mistake. First, if the entire project is unfinished, stop immediately and remove any remaining stain using a wood stripper or rough grit sandpaper.

However, if you have already completed the project and are unhappy with the final results, don’t panic. It is possible to change or cover up solid color stains on wood surfaces without removing them completely. You can use a darker shade of stain to darken an existing lighter shade or like solid oil-based paint in a different color altogether.

Choose a quality product designed for outdoor use and follow the manufacturer’s instructions and how-tos, or you could end up with two-toned wood to show for your efforts, and re-staining starts again. (Read What Size Lag Bolts For Deck Posts)

Wood Bleach

If you don’t like the look of a stain, don’t panic. One solution is using a pressure washer to remove as many coats of the stain as possible. However, if pressure washing doesn’t solve the problem, it may be time to consider using wood bleach. Wood bleach is a chemical solution to lighten or remove the color of wood. It’s commonly used for water-based stains and other discolorations but can also come in handy when you’ve made a mistake with your wood coloring job.

With this, you need a test board to see the reaction with the wood deck and allow it to dry.

Sand The Pieces With SandPaper

If you stained your deck the wrong color, you must sand it down to remove the stain. Sanding helps remove the top layer of the wood, which can be daunting if you have a large deck. However, hand sanding would take a lot of time and effort. To make things easier and quicker, you can use an electric sander. An electric sander will help you sand down your deck faster and more efficiently than hand sanding.

Paint Over Wood Stains

If you have stained your deck with a color you don’t like, then the good news is it’s not too late to fix it. One way to do this is by painting over the wood stain with a new color. However, let it dry completely before you paint over the wood stain. This usually takes around 24-48 hours, depending on how humid and hot the weather is.

Another thing to consider before painting over wood stains is whether your deck was made from treated wood. If your deck was made from untreated wood, then painting over the stain might work out just fine. However, painting over the stain may be bad if your deck was made from treated wood. It could lead to peeling and flaking of paint, or a new finish could run down your railing. Make a line on your wood with tape to stop this, so you don’t end up finishing wood that didn’t have issues.


Avoiding Wrong Stain Color In The First Place

Once you have chosen the stain color for your deck, it’s essential to take all necessary precautions to avoid staining it with a different color. The first step is thoroughly cleaning the deck’s surface using a pressure washer. This will remove any dirt or debris preventing the stain from adhering correctly. (Read Gap Between Pool And Deck)

Before applying the stain, test the color on a small inconspicuous deck area and allow it to dry.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I fix a deck stain mistake by applying a new coat of stain?

A: If you’ve stained your deck the wrong color, applying a new coat of stain may not fix it. You’ll need to remove the existing stain before applying a new one. Use finer sandpaper grits to remove as much of the previous stain as possible.

Q: How long do I have to wait after staining my deck before using it?

A: The time it takes for your newly stained deck to dry depends on several factors, including the weather and type of stain used. Waiting at least 24-48 hours before walking or placing furniture on your deck.

Q: Should I apply one or two coats when staining my deck?

A: You should apply two coats when staining your deck for optimal coverage and protection against weathering and fading. Using just one coat may leave spots where wood is exposed.

Q: Can you change the color of the deck stain?

A: If you’ve stained your deck the wrong color and want to change it, the good news is it’s possible. However, changing the color of a deck stain requires some work. The first thing you need to do is remove as much of the old stain as possible using a paint stripper or sandpaper. Once the old stain has been removed, you can apply a new one in the preferred color.

When choosing a new deck stain color, consider factors like your home’s exterior colors and style and the overall aesthetic of your outdoor space. Choosing a wood tone or natural tone that complements these factors is vital for an overall cohesive look for many yrs. (Read Does A Concrete Patio Increase Property Taxes)

Q: Can you sand off the stain?

A: If you’ve stained your deck the wrong color, you might be wondering if it’s possible to sand off the stain. The answer is yes, but it depends on how long ago you applied the stain and how much UV protection it has. If you’ve only recently applied the stain, then there’s a good chance that sanding with an orbital sander will remove most of it.

Q: How do I fix the wrong color on my deck?

A: If you’ve applied the wrong stain color to your deck, don’t worry – it’s not the world’s end. The first thing you need to do is grab a pencil and note what color you wanted to use. This will help when it comes time to fix the issue.

To fix the wrong color on your deck, you have a couple of options. One option is to sand down the entire deck. Another option is to apply another layer or two of the stain in your desired color over the existing stain.

Q: Can You Put A Different Color Stain Over Stain?

A: If you’ve recently stained your deck but aren’t happy with the color, don’t worry! The key is to remove any dirt, debris, or old coatings that may be on the surface of the wood.

First, use a pressure washer to remove loose debris or dirt from your deck. If this isn’t your case and there are no heavy coats of stain on your deck then sanding down lightly will do for an even colour application. However, if there are layers upon layers of paint or heavy coats of stains on your deck, getting professional help will save time and energy while ensuring great results.

I Stained My Deck The Wrong Color (2)